WP Super Cache Vs W3 Total Cache – Which Performs Better?

Studies have shown that 47% of consumers expect a webpage to load in 2 seconds or less. A 1-second delay in page loading leads the audiences to abandon your page. That means, if you want to develop a conversion-generating website, you should focus on faster page speed for a better user experience.

And, when it comes to boosting your website’s performance or speed, you will find numerous caching tools. As the number is really high, you will obviously find it difficult to select the best one.

Therefore, we have come up with the best two tools for your WordPress cache plugin. In this guide, we will compare WP super cache vs w3 total cache so that you can select the best one for you. So, let’s get started.WP Super Cache Vs W3 Total Cache

WP Super Cache Vs W3 Total Cache – The Differences

A cache is a temporary access area that saves data like files, images, etc., from websites. Caching is significantly beneficial for every site as it can-

  • Improve the speed and performance of your website.
  • Reduce bandwidth consumption.
  • Make sure the content remains available for the visitors.
  • Reduce the load on your hosting server, etc.

WP Super Cache and  W3 Total Cache are not only able to offer these advantages but also come with much more features. In this way, both these WordPress plugins make the caching process extremely easier for the users.

So, without further ado, let’s explore WP super cache vs w3 total cache and see how they work for your site.

1. Overview

Let’s start by knowing the overview of these two WordPress caching plugins.

WP Super Cache

It is a dynamic cache plugin by Automatic that generates static HTML files from your WordPress blog. Once generating the HTML file, your web server starts serving that file instead of the heavy WordPress PHP scripts.

It caches files in three ways, such as-

  • Expert: The fastest method that serves “supercached” static HTML files. It bypasses PHP scripts super fast and makes your site able to cope up quickly with heavy traffic.
  • Simple: This method isn’t that fast, but can serve a supercached file if it exists. Still, you will need a custom permalink in this method.
  • WP-Cache caching: It is mainly used to cache URLs with parameters, pages for known users, and feeds. WP-Cache caching is the most flexible method that cache visits by unknown users.

This plugin is really simple, relatively lightweight, and you can enjoy a hassle-free superfast experience. Besides, WP Super cache syncs with your CDN that will enhance the website’s speed much further.

W3 Total Cache

W3 Total cache designed by BoldGrid can smoothly integrate with your CDN and reduce the webpage’s loading time. It also helps to improve your site by increasing website performance. In fact, with this plugin, you can improve your SERPs ranking, especially for mobile-friendly websites.

However, W3 Total cache can save up to 80% of bandwidth by minifying the HTML, CSS, and JS files of your site. It powers millions of websites by boosting their site performance by 10x. This plugin incorporates transparent CDN management with media library, theme files, and WordPress itself.

2. Setup Process

As not every site owner is tech-savvy, they need plugins with minimal complexity and an easier setup process. Additionally, the less you will spend time on setting up or configuring the plugins, the more you can focus on your site growth. So, here are the setup processes of both these plugins.

You can install WP super cache or W3 total cache plugin just like any other WordPress plugin. Just make sure that you have enabled your custom permalinks. Simply log in to your WordPress admin account and, from the dashboard, navigate to the Plugins > Add New.

Then, type WP Super Cache or W3 Total Cache into the search bar and click on installation. After the installation process is done, don’t forget to Activate the plugin. Now, come to the setup process.

WP Super Cache

WP Super Cache comes with a straightforward setup process; just go to the WordPress dashboard and navigate to Setting > WP Super Cache > Caching On > Update Status. And you are good to go.

W3 Total Cache settings

W3 Total Cache

After installing and activating W3 Total Cache, a new menu called Performance will be added to your dashboard. To set this plugin up, go to Performance > General Setting. Then go through all the provided options to choose the preferred things and save the settings.WP Super Cache settings

If you find it difficult, have a look at their dedicated FAQ wiki and get the insights for configuring this plugin for your website.

2. Features

Both these cache plugins come with plenty of features, and through the features, you can find out the differences easily. So, let’s have a look at them.

WP Super Cache

  • Supports CDN and mobile devices.
  • Has user-friendly export capabilities to transfer cache settings to other sites.
  • The custom cache feature allows you to schedule cache on your own.
  • Comes with an automatic page compression feature.
  • Includes rest API endpoints to access the setting for the plugin.
  • Extensive mod-rewrite capabilities for static caching.

W3 Total Cache

  • Compatible with shared hosting, virtual private/ dedicated servers, and dedicated servers/ clusters.
  • Supports mobile, AMP, and SSL.
  • Implement browser caching, page caching, object, and fragment caching within a few clicks.
  • Minify and compress multiple resources like HTTP, CSS, JS, and databases.
  • Import post attachment directory to a CDN or the WordPress media library.
  • Various security features ensure website safety.

3. Performance

The main purpose of using a cache plugin is to improve the speed and performance of your website. In that case, if the cache plugin itself comes with poor performance, it can’t make your site load faster. Thus, you should consider the performance and speed features of the cache plugins to make a better choice.

As per research, here is a comprehensive comparison between these two cache plugins. comprehensive comparison between wp super cache and w3 total cache

WP Super Cache

A simple cache plugin with easy configuration settings takes less than 2 seconds on average while loading a page. As a free plugin, this type of performance is much appreciable. This tool performs without requiring any complicated settings and procedures. So, without spending a penny, you can enjoy a great loading speed and excellent performance of your website with this plugin.

W3 Total Cache

The page loading time of the W3 total cache remains within 2 seconds for most of the tests. Moreover, it contains several options in its setting option, so if you can utilize them properly, you will get a significant boost in your site’s speed.

4. Support

It’s a major consideration while choosing any plugins, as the beginners and non-techie site owners will require help from experts. Therefore, you should make sure that the plugin you are going to use comes with a reliable support team.

WP Super Cache

After activating the WP super cache plugin, you will see an option on your screen called  “need help”. There they have a dedicated FAQ section with all the necessary questions and their answers provided by the WP super cache experts. If you need additional support, they have a support forum, and there you can ask your question.

The best part is, they offer a debug tab to enter the IP address in the debug plugin and set your cache. It helps to clean the data whenever any error is detected on the user’s site.

W3 Total Cache

It comes with advanced features that include tons of online guides and support with technical knowledge. In fact, you can get extensive and in-depth help from the WordPress support forum for solving your W3 total cache issues. They provide plenty of FAQs, necessary steps, and solutions to solve even minor issues.

In addition, with premium support, you will get an immediate response to all your queries. If you don’t want to spend money, there is also a free option to submit bug reports.

5. Pricing

Basically, pricing is an individual concept; a particular plugin may be expensive for some users while not for others. That’s why here we are sharing the pricing plans of these two cache plugins.

WP Super Cache

With WP super cache, you can experience all the powerful features and cache absolutely free. This free plugin continuously ranks as one of the top WordPress cache plugins of all time. So, if you have a tight budget to spend on but need the best ever solution for your page speed, undoubtedly, this free WP Super cache plugin will be a great option.

W3 Total Cache

W3 total cache comes with two different plans to speed up your WordPress website and rank higher on Google. These plans are-

  • Free Plan: Every user can access this free version, but here the features are restricted.
  • Pro Plan: The Pro version will cost $8.25/mo, which will be billed annually. It’s the ultimate solution to get 10x more speed improvement. With this paid version, you can unlock more possibilities, features, and specific premium solutions.

Conclusion

Faster loading Speed is one of the main keys that can make or break your website’s success. It can ensure an optimal user experience, which will result in decreasing the bounce rate. So, to ensure your web pages load faster, WP super cache and w3 total cache plugins are the best choices.

We have shared the in-depth comparison between WP super cache vs w3 total cache in this guide. Both these plugins are excellent for improving your WordPress website’s performance. So, consider the differences, and make the best choice as per your requirement.

Leave a Comment